|
||||
|
| ||||
|
Europa Classic The CAFE Foundation evaluates the monowheel Europa Subjective Evaluation By Otis Holt |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
N111EU was built with care and a desire to keep it straight and reasonably lightweight. A walk-around reveals pleasing proportions generally enhanced by the paint scheme Kim devised. N111EU is fitted with a prototype Whirlwind constant-speed propeller, which performed well in CAFE Foundation’s evaluations. The Design
T he Europa benefits from the low intersection drag of a mid-wing configuration. The engine compartment overlaps the occupant footwells, placing the engine as far aft as possible to control the center of gravity and minimize wetted area. A tapering wing and an all-moving horizontal stabilizer also help reduce wetted area and drag. At 13.5 psf (pounds per square foot), the wing loading is relatively high for this class of aircraft, contributing to an impressive top speed and to a good ride in turbulence. Another well-thought-out feature is the effective displaced-hinge flap that’s mechanically deployed by the same lever that extends the undercarriage.The Europa’s large single main wheel retracts about halfway into the fuselage. Stiff nylon outriggers with small wheels are located near the outboard ends of the flaps and rotate to a horizontal position when the flaps are retracted. The outriggers are sized to hold the wings nearly level when taxiing. Cables from the rudder pedals are linked directly to a beefy tailwheel, providing positive steering on the ground. The rudder is actuated by a rod linking it to the tailwheel assembly. To accommodate the removable wings, the Europa carries its fuel in a crush-resistant polypropylene tank just aft of the main spar. While I’ve never liked the idea of fuel in the cabin, this solution makes sense when you consider that the aft of spar location is probably the region least likely to receive damage during an accident. One nonstandard feature of N111EU was the static port location inside the aft fuselage, rather than on the fuselage surface. The airspeed calibration table, below, may imply that this location is less than ideal. The Rotax 912UL installed in N111EU performed flawlessly throughout our flight tests and seemed well matched to the aircraft. Our only criticism of the installation relates to the lack of aircraft-standard fittings in the fuel system. The carburetors, fuel pump, and other fuel system components were, instead, fitted with hose nipples designed for use with slip-on hoses and clamps. These fittings leaked when the auxiliary pump was activated. The standard stainless hose clamps were unable to compress the braided hose adequately to make a reliable seal, and we noticed a poor fit between some of the lines and nipples. Also, we observed a minor degradation of the hose material from exposure to auto fuel. Café recommends the installation of aircraft-grade lines and fittings throughout the fuel system as well as a gascolator or quick-drain for the removal of contaminants. Ergonomics and Comfort For an unobstructed view over the cowl when taxiing and for takeoffs and landings, it’s important that the top of the pilot’s head be about one inch below the canopy. As there is no provision for adjustment of the seat or rudder pedals, this is accomplished through removable cushions. Dimensions limiting pilot size include the immutable 44 inches separating the rudder pedals from the wing spar, and the 39-inch seat pan-to-canopy height. Both of these measurements are exclusive of seat cushions. Also, the occupant’s legs are constrained to the 17.5-inch space separating the cabin’s outboard sidewall from the console, so the thighs of larger occupants can limit the control stick’s lateral travel. This is a significant issue as full deflection of the ailerons is occasionally required during takeoffs, as I’ll describe below. For this reason, I’d recommend that builders provide for easy removal of the passenger-side control stick. The console does serve as a comfortable armrest and provides a home for the throttle, finger-actuated brakes, and gear levers. Also mounted on the console are controls for the propeller, parking brake, and choke. All of these are arranged very conveniently for the pilot, and their operation quickly becomes second nature. A door at the rear of the console provides access to the fuel selector, which has Off, On, and Reserve positions. A portion of the main tank, isolated by a saddle shape through which the elevator and rudder controls operate, provides the 2.5-gallon reserve. NACA inlets provide cabin ventilation through eyeball valves that are located on each side of the cabin. The vents generally performed quite well, but the smell of exhaust was occasionally noted during extended periods of slow flight tests. The cabin heat outlet had no provision for canopy defogging; an important feature that would be easy to add. As with most light aircraft available today, neither seat was equipped with a crush zone or any special provision for energy absorption during a crash landing, except for the protection which the seat cushions and landing gear would provide. The shoulder harness attach point was located behind the seat about 10 inches below shoulder height. I was concerned that this would contribute to spinal compression during a crash landing. The cabin ceiling aft of the door would make a better attach point. Ingress and egress was moderately easy. After stepping onto the wing-walk provided, you place one foot on the seat while ducking below the gull-wing door, sit on the seat back, and then lower into position. Some upper body strength is helpful, but most reasonably healthy adults should be able to get in and out without great effort. Ground Operations The brake on the single main wheel is quite effective and easy to use. Pulling a lever alongside the throttle lever activates it, so both tasks go to the pilot’s right hand. I was especially pleased with the operation of the parking brake, a simple one-way valve that traps hydraulic pressure when engaged. Particular care must be taken to ensure that both the front and rear bullet pins securing each gull-wing door are engaged prior to departure. Minor flexing of the door panel was required to line up the rear pin with its receptacle before it could be engaged. It’s easy for one person to push the 800-pound Europa forward or backward on the ground manually using the vertical fin as a grip while steering with the rudder. Takeoff and Climb-out The recommended technique is to keep the tailwheel planted a bit longer than one’s intuition might suggest to assure adequate aileron authority. Steady crosswinds from the right actually make the takeoff easier, whereas those from the left require extra care. My only aborted takeoff occurred during my first encounter with a gust from the left just after having lifted the tailwheel. As I got to know the Europa better, takeoffs became quite enjoyable, and I experienced little difficulty holding to the centerline. The constant-speed prop installed on N111EU permits the engine to develop maximum rated power at 5800 engine rpm during the takeoff roll, so acceleration is quite brisk for just 80 horsepower. The tailwheel is lifted at about 35 to 40 KIAS (knots indicated airspeed), after which the Europa accelerates rapidly to a rotation speed of 45 to 50 KIAS. After a slight pause to accelerate in ground effect, the initial climb should be stabilized at about 65 to 70 KIAS before raising the undercarriage (and flaps) to ensure being above the clean-configuration stall speed. My general impression is that the gross weight limit of 1,300 pounds was appropriate and should not be exceeded. The main wheel is fitted with a bungee assist, which pre-loads the gear downward such that in flight the gear seeks a neutral position about midway through its range of travel. As a result, the forces required for extension and retraction are fairly symmetrical. After pivoting a small mechanical lock with one finger, a firm sidewise pull on the gear/flap extension lever frees it from the down-position detent. An opposing (pull) force is required initially as the lever seeks the neutral point, after which a pushing force growing to about 25 pounds is needed by the time the lever reaches a detent at its forward limit. Gear extension is essentially the reverse process. Though a bit awkward at first, both are easily accommodated with a little practice. Freed from the very substantial drag imposed by the gear and flaps, the Europa accelerates smartly into the climb. After resetting the propeller to bring the Rotax below the 5500 rpm limit for continuous operation, the aircraft is trimmed to 90 to 100 KIAS for sustained climbs, which gives a good balance between forward visibility and rate of climb. The best sustained rate of climb we measured at gross weight (density altitude of 1,000 feet) was 1,297 fpm at 99 mph (CAS, or calibrated airspeed). This equates to an indicated airspeed of 90 KIAS, a good deal faster than the 75 KIAS published as the Vy by the manufacturer. The oil temperature displayed a tendency to increase slowly during sustained climbs in spite of fairly low outside temperatures and would probably impose a limit on the duration of full-power climbs in warmer weather. When stabilized in cruise all engine temperatures were well behaved. Maneuvering stability graph, and Static longitudinal stability graph Stability and Control We flew N111EU to evaluate stability and control with the load ballasted to 15 percent of range aft of the forward limit and again at 85 percent aft of the forward limit. Takeoff weight at the most forward CG (center of gravity) was about 1,150 pounds, and about 1,175 pounds at the most aft. Differences in handling qualities observed between the two loadings were minor, suggesting that the designer’s selection of the center of gravity limits is fairly conservative. Longitudinal Stability Static longitudinal stability showed healthy stick force gradients in all configurations tested. This means the Europa provides the pilot with ample feedback in the form of increasing stick pressure as airspeed deviates more and more from the trim speed, making both unintentional speed gain and unintentional stalls far less likely to occur.
Directional Stability Roll Due to Yaw Maneuvering Stability
Adverse Yaw Roll Rates Spiral stability was neutral. This implies that the Europa will not tend to quickly drop off into a spiral if the pilot’s attention is diverted momentarily. Trim Authority By contrast, elevator trim authority is excellent on N111EU, which is equipped with a panel-mounted position indicator and uses a Mac-servo motor to reposition a servo tab on the all-flying tail. Stalls In the landing configuration, the aircraft displayed a tendency to fall off gently to the right at the stall. Recovery in all cases occurred almost instantly upon release of back pressure on the stick, and it resulted in the loss of no more than 100 feet of altitude when positive recovery techniques were used. CAFE calibrated stall speeds, compensated for instrument and position error, can be found in the measured performance section. Cross-Country Flight Europa N111EU, Sample c.g.
Cross-country performance and economy is quite impressive. A comfortable cruise can be sustained at about 5200 engine rpm while burning 4.2 gph indicating about 125 knots (135 mph CAS). Unfortunately, the Rotax is not equipped with mixture control, and the carburetors do not fully compensate for altitude, so it’s difficult to take advantage of winds aloft and the TAS advantage of high-altitude flight. Nonetheless, we measured a range of 823 miles at 2.5 gph at 107.4 mph TAS (43 mpg). Fuel consumption was as low as 2.1 gph in level flight, and we saw a climb rate of 373 fpm even at 10,000 feet DA (density altitude).
Approach and Landing Successful landings require that pitch attitude at the moment of touchdown be controlled within a fairly narrow range. The outriggers make it advisable to touch down in a wing-level attitude. Approaches to crosswind landings are made at a crab angle to the runway, and the pilot must use rudder to kick the aircraft into runway alignment just prior to touchdown. All of this requires a degree of precision considerably higher than for the typical trainer. Several aborted landings provided my own transition to the Europa with a few humbling moments. When landings are aborted, application of full power has you back in the air almost instantly for a second attempt at landing. The factory discourages wheel landings for several reasons. One is minimal prop clearance (a mere 3.75 inches in the level attitude on N111EU); so prop strikes could result from a botched wheel landing. Also, the Europa sits on the ground at a shallow angle of only about 8 degrees from the horizontal-far less than the stall angle of attack. With the main wheel well forward of the CG, a main-wheel-first landing invariably results in an abrupt relaunch at a nose-high pitch as the tail’s downward momentum forces the wing into a higher angle of attack. Conversely, if the tail touches down too far ahead of the main wheel, the bounce off the main wheel can have a similar result if speed is much above stall. My best landings were achieved by arresting the flare at a slightly tail-low pitch attitude about 1 to 2 feet off the ground, letting the Europa decelerate and settle on its own, cutting power after touchdown and holding the stick back during the roll-out. I found little difficulty with basic directional control after touchdown provided that the stick was held in the full-aft position and positive control is maintained all the way to a full stop. The forward location of the main wheel allows aggressive use of the very effective main-wheel brake without fear of nosing over. It’s a good idea to offset to the right slightly on final approach so that the runway centerline remains in view as a directional reference throughout the landing and roll-out. I also found it helpful to set the final approach speed to about 60 KIAS and carry sufficient power to produce a sink rate of about 300 fpm over the fence, leaving the power in through the flare to touchdown. This puts the approach slightly onto the back side of the power curve, so that the wing is ready to stop flying when power is eased out following touchdown. Regardless of the type of aircraft you are flying prior to the Europa, first flights should be thought of as transition training rather than a simple checkout, and they should include the qualified assistance of someone comfortable in the aircraft’s right seat. Developing the stick and rudder skills required in the monowheel Europa will serve to improve any pilot’s flying, but a tri-gear version of the kit is available for those who would prefer a less challenging alternative. Conclusions Editor’s Note: For more on CAFE’s Europa Classic Aircraft Performance Report, as well as other APRs, visit the CAFE Foundation web site at www.cafefoundation.org. CAFE MEASURED PERFORMANCE, N111EU Europa History Initially, Europas were built with wet lay-up composite construction; the kit now uses prepreg, vacuum-bagged composite moldings with a smooth gel-coat finish. The newer version, the Europa XS, incorporates the following changes: an 18-inch longer wingspan with more wash-out; 9-inch longer ailerons on each side; more propeller ground clearance; more baggage space; a 2-inch deeper footwell for the pilot; a ceramic firewall; an optional 12-gallon auxiliary fuel tank; a 70-pound increase in gross weight; and a longer wheelbase. The cabin modifications in the XS have been made to accommodate larger passengers and to improve comfort. A motorglider wings set is interchangeable on the Europa, and a tri-gear version is now available. It can be converted to trailer-sized mode in just minutes. A variety of engines can be used in this aircraft; the four-stroke, 80-hp Rotax 912UL engine being the standard. The kit supplier also offers a custom trailer, a cowl, a spinner, engine instruments, speed fairings, a lighting kit, and more. There are about 175 Europa builders in the United States, with a
total of more than 600 worldwide. Detailed information is available
by visiting. -Brien A. Seeley About the Builder __________ flight reports __________ |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
If you have any comments or questions contact webmaster@eaa.org |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||